Wednesday, 15 April 2020

Benchmarks in transition videos: Episode 5 - LIBOR fallback: overview

With the increased expectation of some IBORs discontinuation, the overnight benchmark changes and the increasing regulatory requirements related to benchmarks, a clear quantitative finance perspective on the impacts for derivatives is becoming paramount.

We have created a series of introductory videos on the subject of benchmark transition. The videos are available on our Youtube channel.

The fifth episode is an overview to LIBOR fallback. Three more episodes will be dedicated to the fallback.




All the videos will be linked in our LIBOR transition page.



In the current situation, we are also happy to offer virtual/on-line courses/workshop. The configuration is even more flexible that in-person courses as participants in different locations can attend simultaneously and courses can be split in half days to avoid participants lassitude.

Monday, 13 April 2020

Easter

This year, Easter benefits will be reduced to a small set of strange looking eggs.




When times are better, don't hesitate to contact us if you are interested by one of those golf eggs!

LIBOR discontinuation: 2 years to go and calibration

The most talked about date in the LIBOR world, or disappearance thereof, is January 2022. That is 2 years to go!

You may think that there is a problem with my calendar or that I'm still in the mist of new year celebration and I have missed the fact that there is 3 months less than 2 years to go.

But I maintain it is 2 years to go, actually a couple of weeks less than 2 years. In finance there are many conventions to compute the meaning of a tenor. Why is January 2022 separated by 2 year from April 2020 in the LIBOR world? Take a 2 year swap in the most traded currency (USD) with the most traded LIBOR (USD-LIBOR-3M). If you traded a swap on 2-Apr-2020, the effective date was 6-Apr-2020, the last LIBOR coupon will start on 6-Jan-2022 with fixing 4-Jan-2022. The 2-year swaps traded a couple of days ago, on the 2-Apr-2020 were the first 2-year swaps impacted by the January 2022 discontinuation. This justifies the "2 years to go" part of the title.

What about calibration? In a recent post, we indicated that "LIBOR Fallback is not a curve change, it is a contract change!". Does it means that I have to change the contracts/instruments used in my curve calibration? The short answer is "Yes, you do!" If the contracts are changed, with some payments in the swap changed from a "LIBOR fixed in advance" to a "SOFR compounded in arrears with 2-day shift", those details have to be included in the curve calibration. As mentioned above, we have just past the 2-year (swap) mark for the discontinuation date. This is important as it means that on a 2-year swap, now 1/8 of it embed discontinuation. Moreover, if you use 18-month and 2-year swaps in your curve calibration, 1/2 of the 6-month period between those two nodes is impacted. Is the impact large? The only way to know if is to try with actual market figures.

For this we compare three cases: 1) Ignore the existence of discontinuation 2) Take into account the existence of discontinuation for calibration and pricing 3) Take discontinuation into account for pricing but not for calibration in a hybrid way. This last method is incoherent, but may be a natural first step where the change is introduced were it is the simplest.

First we look at the no-discontinuation/no-fallback case. We just use our standard curve calibration procedure. Here to make the things simple and look at one issue at a time we use curves described by zero-coupon rates with linear interpolation on the rate. Obviously for actual market making, you would be more careful on how you calibrate curve, probably using some piecewise constant forward rate and a coherent LIBOR/OIS spread as described in a previous post on "Curve calibration and LIBOR/OIS spread". Here we want to present the difference between the three methods above and the starting point is not our focus as long as we use the same method for all cases.

How does the curve look? The calibration is done as of Thursday 9-Apr and we display the USD-LIBOR-3M forward rates (not the zero-coupon rates) and the SOFR 3-month period forward rate on the same period as LIBOR. The x-axis is the LIBOR fixing date; there is one rate for each good business day. We observe a standard pattern with kinks. The LIBOR/OIS implied spread is represented with the small dots.



We now move to the discontinuation. For that, we need to introduce a couple of hypothesis: the discontinuation date and the adjustment spread. We have selected 1-Jan-2022 for the discontinuation and 25 bps for the spread. The difference is immediately obvious. First there is a clear jump on the graph, from a market implied spread based on the economical reality of LIBOR to a legal contract implied constant spread. After the discontinuation, the spread is constant. The jump in this calibration is more than 15 basis points. This is called in some places a "cliff-effect", it is a cliff-effect only in the graph, not economically. A given instrument has a given fixing date, e.g. the dreaded 4-Jan-2022 mentioned above, you know already that date, you know that it will be after the discontinuation (under our hypothesis of discontinuation on 1-Jan-2022), so there is no surprise, there is no cliff, this will be a SOFR + spread payment. You would be surprise if, like in the first graph, someone was telling you that the value is depend on the LIOBOR economical reality on that date! The cliff can only come from ignoring reality in your calibration/valuation.



Is there a big difference between the different cases? For that we focus only on the period from 1-Jun-2021 to 1-Jun-2022. The rates are displayed in the figure below.

Before that period, all the methods give the same results. The swaps up to 18-month tenors are not affected by the fallback. If we look at longer term, there will be an impact, but a lesser one. It is really around the discontinuation date that the difference is clear. In the graph we have added also the hybrid result with fallback on the pricing but not on the calibration. We see that around the discontinuation date, before it, the no-discontinuation approach is overestimating the rate and after it, it is underestimating it. The difference between the different cases is up to 10 basis points. The market rates are matched perfectly, so you don't see the difference on standard tenor swaps. But if you have to price a non-standard instrument, e.g. a FRA with a start date just before or just after the expected discontinuation date, you may mis-price it by as much as 10 basis points.

Conclusion: Calibrate wisely and make sure that the instruments you price and those you are calibrating to are taking the LIBOR fallback/discontinuation into account for the contract description.

Saturday, 11 April 2020

Benchmarks in transition videos: Episode 4.b - CCP big bang - USD

With the increased expectation of some IBORs discontinuation, the overnight benchmark changes and the increasing regulatory requirements related to benchmarks, a clear quantitative finance perspective on the impacts for derivatives is becoming paramount.

We have created a series of introductory videos on the subject of benchmark transition. The videos are available on our Youtube channel.

The fourth episode (part b) describes the PAI and discounting big bang at CCPs for USD.




All the videos will be linked in our LIBOR transition page.



In the current situation, we are also happy to offer virtual/on-line courses/workshop. The configuration is even more flexible that in-person courses as participants in different locations can attend simultaneously and courses can be split in half days to avoid participants lassitude.

Wednesday, 8 April 2020

Benchmarks in transition videos: Episode 4.a - CCP big bang - EUR

With the increased expectation of some IBORs discontinuation, the overnight benchmark changes and the increasing regulatory requirements related to benchmarks, a clear quantitative finance perspective on the impacts for derivatives is becoming paramount.

We have created a series of introductory videos on the subject of benchmark transition. The videos are available on our Youtube channel.

The fourth episode (part a) describes the PAI and discounting big bang at CCPs for EUR.




All the videos will be linked in our LIBOR transition page.

Monday, 6 April 2020

Benchmarks in transition videos: Episode 3 - New ON benchmarks

With the increased expectation of some IBORs discontinuation, the overnight benchmark changes and the increasing regulatory requirements related to benchmarks, a clear quantitative finance perspective on the impacts for derivatives is becoming paramount.

We have created a series of introductory videos on the subject of benchmark transition. The videos are available on our Youtube channel.

The third episode describes the new overnight benchmarks in USD (SOFR) and EUR (ESTR).




All the videos will be linked in our LIBOR transition page.

Sunday, 5 April 2020

Mandatory IM: Category 5 and 6 delayed by one year

The BCBS has proposed a deferral of final implementation phase of the mandatory IM requirement for non-centrally cleared derivatives. The BCBS press release can be found at: https://www.bis.org/press/p200403a.htm

The BCBS deferral is in line with the proposition that Marc made at the QuantSummit and quoted in the press.

As mentioned previously, we have developed our own code related to a Standard Initial Margin Model (SIMM) used by most of the banks under mandatory IM (currently category 1 to 4). Our implementation is AD compatible and provides the derivatives/sensitivities with respect to all the inputs (all the input amounts).

Note added: By doing some reviews, we have also noticed that some open source code for its computation contains bugs related to the computation of correlations (string comparison bugs).

Benchmarks in transition videos: Episode 2 - Why?

With the increased expectation of some IBORs discontinuation, the overnight benchmark changes and the increasing regulatory requirements related to benchmarks, a clear quantitative finance perspective on the impacts for derivatives is becoming paramount.

We have created a series of introductory videos on the subject of benchmark transition. The videos are available on our Youtube channel.

The second episode is dedicated to the description of why a transition is required.




All the videos will be linked in our LIBOR transition page.

Saturday, 4 April 2020

Benchmarks in transition videos: Episode 1 - Introduction

With the increased expectation of some IBORs discontinuation, the overnight benchmark changes and the increasing regulatory requirements related to benchmarks, a clear quantitative finance perspective on the impacts for derivatives is becoming paramount.

We have created a series of introductory videos on the subject of benchmark transition. The videos are available on our Youtube channel.

The first episode is dedicated to the description of Ibor and Overnight benchmarks.




All the videos will be linked in our LIBOR transition page.

Wednesday, 18 March 2020

LIBOR Fallback is not a curve change, it is a contract change!

In recent consultations, ISDA has proposed a new definitions for the LIBOR fallback. Similar definitions will probably be adopted by CCPs. The exact definitions have still to be clarified (LIBOR tenor or calculation period, calendar for 2 day shift, etc.), but the global idea is to replace a forward looking LIBOR by a backward looking composition on a different period. In previous notes and answers to the consultations, we have explain why the fallback cannot be applied exactly as described in the consultations, some new workaround will be required. Once those clear definitions are available and achievable, how do we include them in our pricing library?

The striking element of that change is not the change from one rate to another but the complete change of the LIBOR-linked derivatives term sheet. The term sheet is changed from a single rate known at the start of the period (or even 2 days before) to a combination of multiple rates known at (or around) the end of the period. This change of term sheet has a direct implication in terms of systems and valuation techniques. It is not possible to look at the fallback from a change of (forwarding) curve perspective. Yes a different curve will be needed, but this is only a very small issue. The main issue is that you have to dynamically change the instrument term sheet. By dynamically, we mean it is not a simple one-off re-booking of the trade in the systems. You may want to do the re-booking once the cessation has taken its full effects, by in the mean time you have to take the trade with its current description and do a what-if type analysis by changing the trade temporarily. The discontinuation date is still uncertain, so you need to do that transformation temporarily (in memory) and have the capacity to do it for several cessation dates, several spreads, several fallback definitions, etc.

This requirements is exactly why we developed the

almost 18 months ago.

We have seen some vendors proposing spread adjustment to RFR curves to price LIBOR swaps in the fallback. This is fine as a toy model to have an overview for vanilla swaps. But if you want a real in depth analysis, how does it work? How do you represent the 2 days shift effect, in particular when the 2 days cover a quarter-end, a year-end or a FOMC meeting? How do you include the difference between LIBOR tenor and calculation period? How do you include the jump on forward rate on the discontinuation date?

The decision to go the "transformer" route was not a random one for us. It was based on several prototypes in a production grade library and running detailed impacts on test portfolios with a market maker requirements in mind. Getting the general level correct by a shift is fine for a first global overview. The next step is to look at the details, at the pricing of short term instruments covering the transition expected date, at the impacts of date shifts, the exact curve shape at each intermediary date, etc. That can be done only by working on the instruments, not on the curves. Each instrument has its own idiosyncrasies that cannot be faked by a curve manipulation.

The inclusion of the jump on forward rate on the discontinuation date is particularly interesting for the moment. The current OIS/LIBOR spreads are very high with respect to the historical median. There is a real impact there. If you have a "fallback curve", how do you represent that? You could say that you would use a technique similar to the one you use for central bank meeting dates jumps. But unfortunately the impact is of a completely different nature. On the day before discontinuation, you have a forward looking LIBOR that covers 3 months. If you use a pseudo-discount factor approach to your LIBOR curve, you have a LIBOR curve for the next 3 months at the LIBOR level. For the 3 months RFR-based forward starting the next day, you need a RFR level (plus a fixed spread). But that RFR rate has an overlap of 3 months minus one day with the LIBOR. On that period, which rate do you use for the pseudo-discount factor curve? The LIBOR level or the RFR (+ spread) level? Today the UD-LIBOR-3M/OIS spread is around 75 bps while the historical median is about 25 bps. There is no way to get away from the contradiction between the levels with a curve approach. There is no reason to expect a convergence of LIBOR to RFR+spread as we appraoch the discontinuation date. And this is only for one single vanilla LIBOR payment, without even looking at the shift, period and composition issues. Even if the LIBOR had a fallback to a clean RFR term rate, this curve approach would not work at the transition.

We advice LIBOR-linked derivative users to implement the "trade transformer" approach in their internal libraries. Using curve based approach is running the risk of a nasty surprise when the actual cessation comes.


Figure 1: Historical time series of realized spread between USD-LIBOR-3M and SOFR compounded. The current crisis does not show yet fully on those figures as the SOFR compounded is backward looking. The full impact will be visible only in 3 months. For a forward looking view of the crisis impact, we refer to the previous post Forward looking the spread between forward looking and backward looking rates.

Figure 2: Distribution of realized spread between USD-LIBOR-3M and SOFR compounded with teh current median. The most recent realizations are in lighter colours. The most recent ones are mainly above the current median and we can expect that the median will increase in the coming months. More details are available in the previous post LIBOR Fallback: a median in a crisis.



We have done many other developments around the analysis of valuation and data in the context of the LIBOR fallback. This includes analysis of value transfer impacts, forward spreads, minimum and maximum spreads, discounting big bang, estimations based on forward curves with calibration using spread control (see Curve calibration and LIBOR-OIS spread).

Don't hesitate to reach out to discuss how those developments could be of interest in the context of the management of your portfolio.