The ISDA proposed LIBOR fallback mechanism is based on a 5-year historical median estimate. If the LIBOR discontinuation take place as expected in January 2022, we already have a certain portion of the required historical data.
In this analysis, to keep the number of variables low, we look only at USD-LIBOR-3M and suppose that the announcement date is 1 September 2021 (3 month before January 2022). We interpret the "5 year of history" as meaning 5 years of LIBOR fixing for which we have the relevant SOFR fixings. This means we actually use 5 years and 3 months of overnight data (other interpretation of "5 years history" are possible). The LIBOR fixing are from 29 June 2016 to 29 June 2021.
We can plot the historical data from the known period (29 June 2016 to 13 March 2020); the histogram of the data is provided below. The figure also displays the median (as per ISDA proposal) and the median (for comparison). The median is 26.6 bps and the mean 29.2 bps.
There is still the period from 16 March 2020 to 29 June 2021 which is unknown. The proposal is to use the median. We have 876 data points out of the 1260 required. We can already put a hard bound on the lowest and highest possible median spread (conditional to our date hypothesis). The lowest median possible is 20.2 bps and the highest median possible is 36.5 bps. Those figures are represented below.
What about the mean? The mean depends on the exact value of each number, and there is no a priori bound on the individual spreads, so no a priori bound on the mean either. We can nevertheless create some "what-if" analysis. For that we use two extreme scenarios: one with all the remaining spreads at 0 bps and one with all the remaining spread at 100 bps. The graph of those values is proposed below.
The different daily spreads are not independent. There is significant overlap between the overnight rates used in consecutive daily spreads. The spreads tend to cluster, creating a trend in the median evolution. Where are we today (or more exactly were are we in the combination of LIBOR from 3 months ago and overnight up to today)? In the figure below, the have colour-coded the different occurrences. The lighter colours represent the more recent ones, each colour representing one of the 8 groups of 10 prints (a total of 80 recent print are in lighter colours).
The trend in the last months has been to be higher that the median. Note that the above figure do not include the LIBOR rates from the recent turbulent weeks; those will appear in the statistics only in a couple of months. Our best predication of those (see our recent post on Forward looking the spread between forward looking and backward looking rates) is that there will soon be very high spreads (above 100 bps).
This lead us to an embedded option in the fallback proposal. We mention our best estimate of the spreads in the coming months. Suppose that our estimation is perfect, are we sure that those spread will be included in the actual spread computation? The computation of the spread will be done on the announcement date (not on the cessation date). The announcement date will be decided by IBA and the panel banks, the procedure is thus giving a (free) option to the panel banks. Even disregarding the potential material nonpublic information embedded in the decision, there is a real option of non negligible value. Suppose that the option is exercised today and the announcement is made today (for an actual cessation in January 2022), what would be the impact? It is graphically depicted in the figure below. The direct impact would be an estimated margin of 24.5 bps, which is a decrease of 2 bps with respect to the first estimate in this post. Maybe more importantly it also removes the possibility of the spread going up to 36.5 bps which would be the case if all (market) spreads in the next 2 years or so were to be above 36.5 bps. The announcement option has a potential value of as much as 12 bps on all transactions with fixings post January 2022.
What are your options with regards to the fallback and how do you plan to exercise them? Don't hesitate to contact us to estimate them.
We have done many other developments around the analysis of spread data in the context of the LIBOR fallback. This includes analysis of value transfer impacts, forward spreads, minimum and maximum spreads, estimations based on forward curves with calibration using spread control (see Curve calibration and LIBOR-OIS spread).
Don't hesitate to reach out to discuss how those developments could be of interest in the context of the management of your portfolio.
Saturday, 14 March 2020
Libor transition plans: Marc quoted in the press
Comments by Marc regarding the impact of the pandemic on some market infrastructure transformation were reported in the press yesterday: Pandemic threatens Libor transition plans.
The comments were related to LIBOR transition and to uncleared margin rules.
Unfortunately, "A spokesperson for the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority – Libor’s regulator – did not respond to a request for comment."
The comments were related to LIBOR transition and to uncleared margin rules.
Unfortunately, "A spokesperson for the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority – Libor’s regulator – did not respond to a request for comment."
A spokesperson for the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority – Libor’s regulator – did not respond to a request for comment.
A spokesperson for the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority – Libor’s regulator – did not respond to a request for comment.
Thursday, 12 March 2020
Forward looking the spread between forward looking and backward looking rates
Forward looking the spread between forward looking and backward looking rates or estimating the market misestimation
The planned approach to adjustment spread in the new derivative LIBOR fallback arrangements are based on historical data. The spread historical data is based on one side the LIBOR forward looking rates and on the other side on the backward looking compounding setting in arrears.
This arrangement creates a spread which is a mixture of credit spread and market misestimation (see A Quant Perspective on IBOR Fallback consultation results, Section 5.2 for previous remarks on this). What is happening to that spread with the current crisis? By definition of the spread itself, we will be able to analyse this only in 3 months time, when all the overnight rates prints are known and we can compare the then backward looking overnight rate to the today forward looking LIBOR rate.
But it is possible to do a little bit better. We know the LIBOR rates over the last 3 months and we can project the overnight rates for the next 3 months. That does not really help us for the spread corresponding to today fixing, but it will help for the LIBOR fixing over the past three months. It is possible to get an estimate of the surprise (surprise cut in this case) that has already been realised.
The following graph is the result of that exercise for USD-LIBOR-3M and USD-SOFR. The LIBOR rates (dark blue line) are know up to today. The SOFR compounding rate in arrears based on the actual fixing (light gray line) are known up to the period corresponding to the fixing from 3 months ago. The projected in arrears for the 3 months up to today (dark grey) are based on known fixing up to today and projected fixing up to the end of the 3-month period. The spreads up to 3 months ago (yellow) are fully known and the spreads up to today are partly known (red) with the LIBOR side fully known and the SOFR side partly known.
We can see that the (projected) data already includes spike in the spread due to the surprise cut. The spike is above 100 bps. On the other side, for the fully forward looking LIBOR versus the fully forward looking SOFR (last red point on the graph), this is a spread without any unexpected element of monetary policy, has a spread larger than the average/median over the last years but is very far away from the spike. It does not mean that the credit crisis is suddenly seen as less severe over the last days, only that the market is not expecting unexpected policy changes.
We have done many other developments around the analysis of spread data in the context of the LIBOR fallback. This includes analysis of minimum and maximum spreads, estimations based on forward curves with calibration using spread control (see Curve calibration and LIBOR-OIS spread).
Don't hesitate to reach out to discuss how those developments could be of interest in the context of your portfolio management.
The planned approach to adjustment spread in the new derivative LIBOR fallback arrangements are based on historical data. The spread historical data is based on one side the LIBOR forward looking rates and on the other side on the backward looking compounding setting in arrears.
This arrangement creates a spread which is a mixture of credit spread and market misestimation (see A Quant Perspective on IBOR Fallback consultation results, Section 5.2 for previous remarks on this). What is happening to that spread with the current crisis? By definition of the spread itself, we will be able to analyse this only in 3 months time, when all the overnight rates prints are known and we can compare the then backward looking overnight rate to the today forward looking LIBOR rate.
But it is possible to do a little bit better. We know the LIBOR rates over the last 3 months and we can project the overnight rates for the next 3 months. That does not really help us for the spread corresponding to today fixing, but it will help for the LIBOR fixing over the past three months. It is possible to get an estimate of the surprise (surprise cut in this case) that has already been realised.
The following graph is the result of that exercise for USD-LIBOR-3M and USD-SOFR. The LIBOR rates (dark blue line) are know up to today. The SOFR compounding rate in arrears based on the actual fixing (light gray line) are known up to the period corresponding to the fixing from 3 months ago. The projected in arrears for the 3 months up to today (dark grey) are based on known fixing up to today and projected fixing up to the end of the 3-month period. The spreads up to 3 months ago (yellow) are fully known and the spreads up to today are partly known (red) with the LIBOR side fully known and the SOFR side partly known.
We can see that the (projected) data already includes spike in the spread due to the surprise cut. The spike is above 100 bps. On the other side, for the fully forward looking LIBOR versus the fully forward looking SOFR (last red point on the graph), this is a spread without any unexpected element of monetary policy, has a spread larger than the average/median over the last years but is very far away from the spike. It does not mean that the credit crisis is suddenly seen as less severe over the last days, only that the market is not expecting unexpected policy changes.
We have done many other developments around the analysis of spread data in the context of the LIBOR fallback. This includes analysis of minimum and maximum spreads, estimations based on forward curves with calibration using spread control (see Curve calibration and LIBOR-OIS spread).
Don't hesitate to reach out to discuss how those developments could be of interest in the context of your portfolio management.
Sunday, 8 March 2020
Signing the LIBOR fallback protocol: a cautionary tale (2)
Following recent market moves, the graph accompanying the cautionary tale published in Risk.Net has been updated.
The full text is available on Risk.Net website (subscription required):
The full text is available on Risk.Net website (subscription required):
Updated without comment!
Sunday, 1 March 2020
Sunday, 2 February 2020
Discounting transition: big bang impacts
CCPs have announced that they will change the PAI/collateral rate in
USD from Effective Fed Fund rate (EFFR) to SOFR. This will be done as a
big bang approach, not in line will the planned paced transition set by ARRC in 2017. The planned date for the big bang transition at CME and LCH is Friday 16 October 2020. Some description for CME
can be found on their website; we have not found a similar description
for LCH, even if it appears that the methodology will be similar.
CCPs are planning a big bang-like collateral and discounting transition for USD. In theory this transition is done with value compensation and risk exchange at fair market value. Such a transition would conduce to the absence of value and risk impact. But by definition of big bang, the transition is done in an illiquid market for which the fair theoretical value is unknown. To understand the actual impact on valuation and risk, one has to look at the practical details of the transition and how the absence of data for half of the required theoretical quantities is overcome in practice. The resulting situation prompts exotic convexity adjustments for cleared swap and unknown valuation for non-cleared products.
The document, in the muRisQ Advisory Market Infrastructure Analysis series, is titled
and is available on SSRN with the reference
Henrard, Marc P. A., Discounting transition: big bang impacts. Market Infrastructure Analysis, muRisQ Advisory, February 2020. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3530464.
Other post related to the discounting transition: Change in collateral rate at CCP: quant perspective.
CCPs are planning a big bang-like collateral and discounting transition for USD. In theory this transition is done with value compensation and risk exchange at fair market value. Such a transition would conduce to the absence of value and risk impact. But by definition of big bang, the transition is done in an illiquid market for which the fair theoretical value is unknown. To understand the actual impact on valuation and risk, one has to look at the practical details of the transition and how the absence of data for half of the required theoretical quantities is overcome in practice. The resulting situation prompts exotic convexity adjustments for cleared swap and unknown valuation for non-cleared products.
The document, in the muRisQ Advisory Market Infrastructure Analysis series, is titled
Discounting transition: big bang impacts
and is available on SSRN with the reference
Henrard, Marc P. A., Discounting transition: big bang impacts. Market Infrastructure Analysis, muRisQ Advisory, February 2020. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3530464.
Other post related to the discounting transition: Change in collateral rate at CCP: quant perspective.
Labels:
CCP,
Collateral,
Market infrastructure,
Multi-curve framework
Tuesday, 21 January 2020
Signing the LIBOR fallback protocol: a cautionary tale
As Orwell's Room 101 beckons for LIBOR publication, muRisQ Advisory's Marc Henrard warns of potential pitfall in the fallback protocol.
This is the Risk.Net introduction to Marc's comment about the cleared/uncleared fragmentation of the market due to the design of the IBOR fallback.
The full text is available on Risk.Net website (subscription required):
Figure from the above published comment.
Note that the issue of the market fragmentation will be particularly visible in EUR where it is expected that EUR-LIBOR will be discontinued at the end of 2021 and EUR-EURIBOR will continue to exist probably for a further 5 years. It appears that the EUR-LIBOR fallback will be done directly to ESTR and not to EUR-EURIBOR as suggested in our answer to the ISDA EUR fallback consultation. Any payment originating from LIBOR fallback will be easy to compare to an actual EUR-EURIBOR payment (see also the post about the EUR curve shape not in line with ISDA fallback at all).
The discrepancy between fallback contaminated and clean versions of LIBOR payments should be taken into account in bond reference rate switch from LIBOR to SONIA. A popular method seems to infer the adjustment spread for bonds from the swap market as reported in Nationwide and Lloyds win nod for Sonia bond switch (subscription required). But those spreads are based on the historical past spread, not on the forecast of actual LIBOR-like value. Obviously the switches have been done with the approval of the note-holder, but was that approval based on a clear understanding by the note-holders of what was behind those contaminated cleared swap market figures?
Saturday, 18 January 2020
Answer to ISDA consultation on EUR-LIBOR and EUR-EURIBOR fallback
ISDA consultation regarding EUR-LIBOR and EURIBOR fallback closes in a couple of days. As for the previous consultation, we have provided a detailed answer. The text of our answer can be found on SSRN: Answer to ``Supplemental Consultation on Spread and Term Adjustments, including Final Parameters thereof, for Fallbacks in Derivatives Referencing EUR LIBOR and EURIBOR, as well as other less widely used IBORs'' issued by ISDA http://ssrn.com/abstract=3520619.
To those generic answer, there are two EUR specific issues that should be emphasised. The first one is positive and is the existence of two benchmarks (EUR-LIBOR and EUR-EURIBOR) with one of them expected to outlast the other by several years. The surviving benchmark should be used as the first step of the fallback for the other benchmark. The second issue is negative and is due to the fact that the planned fallback benchmark, ESTR, has been published only since 1 October 2019. Data preceding that date are for some part not intended for use as benchmark by the administrator and regulator and for the older part not regulation compliant. The only ESTR data acceptable is the one officially published as a benchmark, i.e. data for dates after 1 October 2019.
We suggest once more to ISDA to fundamentally review the decision to base the fallback on the compounding setting in arrears and historical mean approaches.
The answer should be read in conjunction with our previous answer and publication, including a couple of paper in peer reviewed journals.
Answer to``Consultation on Certain Aspects of Fallbacks for Derivatives Referencing GBP LIBOR, CHF LIBOR, JPY LIBOR, TIBOR, Euroyen TIBOR and BBSW'' issued by ISDA. October 2018.
Available at http://multi-curve-framework.blogspot.com/2018/10/isda-consultation-on-libor-fallback-my.html.
LIBOR Fallback transformers!
Market Infrastructure blog, muRisQ Advisory, October 2018.
Available at https://murisq.blogspot.com/2018/10/libor-fallback-transformers.html.
A Quant Perspective on IBOR Fallback consultation results.
Market infrastructure analysis, muRisQ Advisory, January 2019.
Available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=3308766.
Answer to ``Supplemental Consultation on Spread and Term Adjustments for Fallbacks in Derivatives Referencing USD LIBOR, CDOR and HIBOR and Certain Aspects of Fallbacks for Derivatives Referencing SOR'' issued by ISDA. July 2019.
Available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3415930.
Answer to ``Consultation on Final Parameters for the Spread and Term Adjustments in Derivatives Fallbacks for Key IBORs'' issued by ISDA. October 2019.
Available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3476530.
LIBOR fallback and quantitative finance. Risks, 7(88), August 2019. Open Access article available at https://doi.org/10.3390/risks7030088.
LIBOR: Don't fallback, step forward. Wilmott Magazine, November 2019.
Fallback protocol signature: a cautionary tale. Risk.Net, January 2020, to appear.
The figure is extracted from the post related to the "EURIBOR: The market does not believe in ISDA fallback in the next 10 years!"
Conclusion:
The consultation is based on question similar to the previous consultations. The answers we provided to those consultation and the quantitative literature related to the same subject can be used to understand why the proposed solutions are not acceptable.To those generic answer, there are two EUR specific issues that should be emphasised. The first one is positive and is the existence of two benchmarks (EUR-LIBOR and EUR-EURIBOR) with one of them expected to outlast the other by several years. The surviving benchmark should be used as the first step of the fallback for the other benchmark. The second issue is negative and is due to the fact that the planned fallback benchmark, ESTR, has been published only since 1 October 2019. Data preceding that date are for some part not intended for use as benchmark by the administrator and regulator and for the older part not regulation compliant. The only ESTR data acceptable is the one officially published as a benchmark, i.e. data for dates after 1 October 2019.
We suggest once more to ISDA to fundamentally review the decision to base the fallback on the compounding setting in arrears and historical mean approaches.
The answer should be read in conjunction with our previous answer and publication, including a couple of paper in peer reviewed journals.
Answer to``Consultation on Certain Aspects of Fallbacks for Derivatives Referencing GBP LIBOR, CHF LIBOR, JPY LIBOR, TIBOR, Euroyen TIBOR and BBSW'' issued by ISDA. October 2018.
Available at http://multi-curve-framework.blogspot.com/2018/10/isda-consultation-on-libor-fallback-my.html.
LIBOR Fallback transformers!
Market Infrastructure blog, muRisQ Advisory, October 2018.
Available at https://murisq.blogspot.com/2018/10/libor-fallback-transformers.html.
A Quant Perspective on IBOR Fallback consultation results.
Market infrastructure analysis, muRisQ Advisory, January 2019.
Available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=3308766.
Answer to ``Supplemental Consultation on Spread and Term Adjustments for Fallbacks in Derivatives Referencing USD LIBOR, CDOR and HIBOR and Certain Aspects of Fallbacks for Derivatives Referencing SOR'' issued by ISDA. July 2019.
Available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3415930.
Answer to ``Consultation on Final Parameters for the Spread and Term Adjustments in Derivatives Fallbacks for Key IBORs'' issued by ISDA. October 2019.
Available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3476530.
LIBOR fallback and quantitative finance. Risks, 7(88), August 2019. Open Access article available at https://doi.org/10.3390/risks7030088.
LIBOR: Don't fallback, step forward. Wilmott Magazine, November 2019.
Fallback protocol signature: a cautionary tale. Risk.Net, January 2020, to appear.
The figure is extracted from the post related to the "EURIBOR: The market does not believe in ISDA fallback in the next 10 years!"
Figure 3: Time series of EURIBOR and (pre-)ESTR compounded with 6-month underlying period.
Thursday, 16 January 2020
Marc's workshop at QuantMinds International 2020
Marc Henrard will present a workshop and a seminar at
which will take place from Monday 11 May to Friday 15 May 2020 in Hamburg. The agenda of the conference can be found on the organizer web site:
Marc's workshop, will take place on Friday 15 May and will be titled Benchmarks in transition: Quantitative perspective on benchmarks, transition, fallback and regulation..
The workshop agenda can be found on the organizer website at https://informaconnect.com/quantminds-international/ibor-workshop/
The workshop can also be run as an in-house course tailor made to your needs as described on our training page related to benchmarks.
We will add the details of the talk closer to the date.
Don't hesitate to reach out if you want to meet during the conference.
QuantMinds International
which will take place from Monday 11 May to Friday 15 May 2020 in Hamburg. The agenda of the conference can be found on the organizer web site:
Marc's workshop, will take place on Friday 15 May and will be titled Benchmarks in transition: Quantitative perspective on benchmarks, transition, fallback and regulation..
The workshop agenda can be found on the organizer website at https://informaconnect.com/quantminds-international/ibor-workshop/
The workshop can also be run as an in-house course tailor made to your needs as described on our training page related to benchmarks.
We will add the details of the talk closer to the date.
Don't hesitate to reach out if you want to meet during the conference.
Saturday, 11 January 2020
Marc's presentation at the Quant Summit Europe 2020
Marc Henrard will present a seminar at the
which will take place on Wednesday 11 and Thursday 12 March 2020 in London. The agenda of the conference can be found on the organizer web site:
Marc's talk, will be titled LIBOR fallback: the cost of a signature.
Talk's agenda:
As a speaker at the summit, we can offer our guests a 20% discount. Contact us for the discount code.
Don't hesitate to reach out if you want to meet during the summit.
Quant Summit Europe
which will take place on Wednesday 11 and Thursday 12 March 2020 in London. The agenda of the conference can be found on the organizer web site:
Marc's talk, will be titled LIBOR fallback: the cost of a signature.
Talk's agenda:
- ISDA fallback methodology
- Value transfer in the fallback
- ISDA protocol signature crystallize the value transfer: what is its cost?
As a speaker at the summit, we can offer our guests a 20% discount. Contact us for the discount code.
Don't hesitate to reach out if you want to meet during the summit.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











